A prize that has never been revoked, even in hindsight
Despite the lobotomy award and a small number of other selections that appear deeply questionable by modern medical standards, the Nobel Foundation has maintained a strict policy of never revoking a prize once awarded, meaning even widely criticized past decisions remain part of the official historical record.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did the 1949 lobotomy prize become so controversial?
While lobotomy was considered a legitimate and even groundbreaking psychiatric treatment at the time, subsequent decades of research revealed the procedure often caused severe, irreversible harm to patients, leading many in the medical community to view the original award as a significant historical error.
Can the medicine prize be awarded for animal or non-human research?
The prize is specifically intended to recognize discoveries in physiology or medicine that benefit human health, so while foundational research is frequently conducted using animal models, the recognized contribution must ultimately connect to advancing human medical understanding.