Why recognition boards tend to fade after the first week
The initial novelty of a new tool or ritual generates a burst of engagement regardless of whether the underlying habit is sustainable. A kudos board specifically fades when posting requires remembering unprompted, takes real effort to write, or lives somewhere outside the team's normal workflow -- all fixable with the right setup rather than reasons to abandon the idea.
Peer recognition versus manager recognition
A kudos board captures a different signal than formal manager praise or performance review comments -- it surfaces the day-to-day help and effort that a manager often doesn't directly witness, like a teammate walking someone through a tricky problem. The two are complementary, not substitutes for each other.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should kudos boards be public to the whole team or private between two people?
Public, generally -- part of the value is other team members seeing what kind of help and effort gets recognized, which reinforces the behavior more broadly. A private thank-you is valuable too, but it does not build the same shared culture that a visible board does.
What if the same few people always give and receive kudos?
That pattern is worth noticing rather than ignoring -- it can mean genuinely uneven contribution, or it can mean some team members' help is simply less visible. A periodic prompt aimed at quieter team members, or specifically asking "who haven't we recognized lately," can surface contributions the board is currently missing.