Depth and undertone are two separate problems
A shade that looks "right" in brightness but slightly off in warmth is one of the most common foundation-matching complaints, and it almost always comes down to conflating depth (how light or dark) with undertone (warm or cool). Solving for both separately, rather than picking a single shade based on lightness alone, is what actually fixes the mismatch.
Store lighting is working against you more than you think
Cosmetics counters are frequently lit with warm, flattering, yellow-toned lighting designed to make everything look good in the moment — which is exactly the environment where a shade match is least reliable. Building the natural-light check and the wait-for-oxidation step into your routine directly counteracts both of the biggest sources of a bad match.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does my foundation look perfect in the store but wrong at home?
It's usually a combination of warm, flattering store lighting distorting the color and oxidation shifting the shade slightly darker after wearing it for a while — both effects that a quick counter test in artificial light won't reveal.
Should I match foundation to my face or my neck?
Match it to your neck and jawline, not just your face — since face and neck are the areas most visible together, a shade that blends seamlessly at the jawline will look natural overall, even if it seems slightly different from your face alone under close inspection.