Playtime is the biggest factor
Both the PlayStation Store and the Microsoft Store treat little or no playtime as a strong signal that the purchase was not really used, which raises the chance of approval. If you have logged significant hours, the platform generally assumes normal use and may deny the request. Cancelling a pre-order before its release date is the one clear exception β that is refunded in full almost automatically, without needing a specific reason.
If you access games through a subscription
If you play through a subscription library such as PlayStation Plus or Xbox Game Pass, an individual game refund does not apply, because you never purchased that specific title outright. Instead, manage the subscription itself β pause or cancel it if you no longer want access, or check the subscription tier that unlocks the games you actually play. If you separately buy a game or add-on with real money while subscribed, that individual purchase can still be refunded through the normal process.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a pre-ordered game always refundable before release?
On most platforms, cancelling a pre-order before release is refunded in full with no reason required, but once the game is released and some time passes, the normal refund conditions apply instead.
Can I get a refund for a game I access through a subscription?
Content you play through a subscription like a game-pass library is not an individual purchase, so it is not eligible for its own refund β you cancel the subscription itself instead.