Hardware wear is a real possibility
Proximity sensors do not have moving parts, but the infrared emitter and receiver can degrade slowly over years of use, or get physically damaged after a drop that does not otherwise crack the screen. If cleaning, removing the screen protector, and restarting the phone all fail, this is a case where a repair shop or manufacturer diagnostic is worth the visit.
Dark or textured cases can also interfere
It is not just screen protectors β a case with a lip that extends over the top edge of the screen, especially a dark-colored or textured one, can sometimes block the sensor's infrared path enough to cause misreads. If removing the screen protector does not help, try the phone without its case as well.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does my screen stay off even after the call ends?
This usually means the sensor is stuck reporting 'covered' even when nothing is near it. Restarting the phone typically clears a stuck sensor reading; if it recurs frequently, it points toward a hardware issue rather than a one-off glitch.
Is there a way to just turn the sensor off permanently?
Stock Android does not offer a simple toggle for this, but some phone brands or third-party dialer apps include a setting to disable proximity-based screen locking during calls, trading the convenience of automatic locking for consistent behavior.